| Horcruxes and Books [message #282316] |
Mi, 21 Juni 2006 09:39 |
|
This is just a rough idea which have not seen discussed here.
There are 6+1 books and 6+1 soul pieces.
I ask myself whether it could be that each soul fragment is related to
one book.
The "self"-piece is related to book 7, because Harry will fight V
himself.
The diary relates to CoS.
What if there was a loose association of each of the 6 Horcruxs with
each
of the first 6 books.
Maybe a place or so.
For instance, maybe there is a clue or something in the Shreaking Shack
(PoA clue),
and in the room of requirements (OotP).
Andreas
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282329 ] |
Mi, 21 Juni 2006 22:10 |
|
If this were the case, here's a few ideas.
1. Nagini? (The snake near the begining could be...)
2. Diary
3. Something at the potter's house?
4. So many things... (Triwizard cup, Pettigrew's hand, etc)
5. I would guess the locket that people think was from R.A.B.
6. Again, could be lots of things...
Just a few ideas.
acd wrote:
> This is just a rough idea which have not seen discussed here.
>
> There are 6+1 books and 6+1 soul pieces.
> I ask myself whether it could be that each soul fragment is related to
> one book.
> The "self"-piece is related to book 7, because Harry will fight V
> himself.
> The diary relates to CoS.
> What if there was a loose association of each of the 6 Horcruxs with
> each
> of the first 6 books.
> Maybe a place or so.
> For instance, maybe there is a clue or something in the Shreaking Shack
> (PoA clue),
> and in the room of requirements (OotP).
>
> Andreas
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282358 ] |
Do, 22 Juni 2006 09:41 |
|
On 21 Jun 2006 00:39:07 -0700, "acd" <acd4usenet [at] lycos.de> wrote:
>This is just a rough idea which have not seen discussed here.
>
>There are 6+1 books and 6+1 soul pieces.
>I ask myself whether it could be that each soul fragment is related to
>one book.
>The "self"-piece is related to book 7, because Harry will fight V
>himself.
>The diary relates to CoS.
>What if there was a loose association of each of the 6 Horcruxs with
>each
>of the first 6 books.
>Maybe a place or so.
>For instance, maybe there is a clue or something in the Shreaking Shack
>(PoA clue),
>and in the room of requirements (OotP).
>
>Andreas
Well, Book 1 was all about the self piece,as that's the one we see.
The 7th's the final piece, and the surprise of where it is.
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282359 ] |
Do, 22 Juni 2006 09:43 |
|
On 21 Jun 2006 13:10:04 -0700, "Tuvas" <tuvas21 [at] gmail.com> wrote:
>If this were the case, here's a few ideas.
>
>1. Nagini? (The snake near the begining could be...)
He won't have 2 snake horcruxes.
>2. Diary
>3. Something at the potter's house?
>4. So many things... (Triwizard cup, Pettigrew's hand, etc)
You people really think he'll trust his precious Soul Bit to a known
traitor?
>5. I would guess the locket that people think was from R.A.B.
>6. Again, could be lots of things...
The Ring.
7. The surprise.
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282363 ] |
Do, 22 Juni 2006 11:58 |
|
There are only 6 horcruxes, the person (Voldemort) is the 7th peice.
These are the most likely:
1. Riddle's Diary - Destroyed
2. Marvolo's Ring - Destroyed
3. The Locket - Presumably Destroyed
4. Hufflepuff's Cup
5. Something of Ravenclaw's or of Gryffindor's
6. Nagini
7. Voldemort
If the theory of Harry being a horcruxe, then he would most likely
replace 5.
Toon wrote:
> On 21 Jun 2006 13:10:04 -0700, "Tuvas" <tuvas21 [at] gmail.com> wrote:
>
> >If this were the case, here's a few ideas.
> >
> >1. Nagini? (The snake near the begining could be...)
>
> He won't have 2 snake horcruxes.
>
> >2. Diary
> >3. Something at the potter's house?
> >4. So many things... (Triwizard cup, Pettigrew's hand, etc)
>
>
> You people really think he'll trust his precious Soul Bit to a known
> traitor?
>
> >5. I would guess the locket that people think was from R.A.B.
>
> >6. Again, could be lots of things...
>
> The Ring.
>
> 7. The surprise.
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282384 ] |
Do, 22 Juni 2006 23:13 |
|
Toon wrote:
> On 21 Jun 2006 13:10:04 -0700, "Tuvas" <tuvas21 [at] gmail.com> wrote:
>
> >If this were the case, here's a few ideas.
> >
> >1. Nagini? (The snake near the begining could be...)
>
> He won't have 2 snake horcruxes.
I wasn't refering to him having 2 snake horcruxes, rather, that the
snake found in book 1 could be Nagini. Just a small posibility, but,
well, yah.
>
> >2. Diary
> >3. Something at the potter's house?
> >4. So many things... (Triwizard cup, Pettigrew's hand, etc)
>
>
> You people really think he'll trust his precious Soul Bit to a known
> traitor?
>
> >5. I would guess the locket that people think was from R.A.B.
>
> >6. Again, could be lots of things...
>
> The Ring.
>
> 7. The surprise.
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282386 ] |
Do, 22 Juni 2006 23:46 |
|
On 2006-06-22 17:13:38 -0400, "Tuvas" <tuvas21 [at] gmail.com> said:
>
> Toon wrote:
>> On 21 Jun 2006 13:10:04 -0700, "Tuvas" <tuvas21 [at] gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>>> If this were the case, here's a few ideas.
>>>
>>> 1. Nagini? (The snake near the begining could be...)
>>
>> He won't have 2 snake horcruxes.
>
> I wasn't refering to him having 2 snake horcruxes, rather, that the
> snake found in book 1 could be Nagini. Just a small posibility, but,
> well, yah.
The only problem is that the snake in PS/SS was a constrictor. As we
see when Nagini strikes Arthur Weasley, she is fanged.
--
Enjoy,
Zolak of Twylo
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282396 ] |
Fr, 23 Juni 2006 06:58 |
|
On 22 Jun 2006 14:13:38 -0700, "Tuvas" <tuvas21 [at] gmail.com> wrote:
>I wasn't refering to him having 2 snake horcruxes, rather, that the
>snake found in book 1 could be Nagini. Just a small posibility, but,
>well, yah.
So, V changes her species and gender?
|
|
|
| Re: Horcruxes and Books [message #282400 ] |
Fr, 23 Juni 2006 09:07 |
|
Toon schrieb:
> On 21 Jun 2006 00:39:07 -0700, "acd" <acd4usenet [at] lycos.de> wrote:
>
> >This is just a rough idea which have not seen discussed here.
> >
> >There are 6+1 books and 6+1 soul pieces.
> >I ask myself whether it could be that each soul fragment is related to
> >one book.
> >The "self"-piece is related to book 7, because Harry will fight V
> >himself.
> >The diary relates to CoS.
> Well, Book 1 was all about the self piece,as that's the one we see.
> The 7th's the final piece, and the surprise of where it is.
But if my assumption were true, we cannot have two books about the self
piece.
I thought that the mirror of erised may help Harry to find one of the
remaining
Horcruxes, that would be the help piece from Book 1.
Andreas
|
|
|
