| A crazy idea [message #281759] |
So, 11 Juni 2006 10:01 |
|
Hi, don't post here much but I have a question, and it hasn't been mentioned
as far as I know.
In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
We've seen Polly Juice potion a couple of times now.
Makes more scense that Wormtail was staying with him plus the title half
blood prince makes more sence to me.
Not to mention the look of hatred on Snape's face when he killed DD and the
alledged fault Dumbledore made when trusting Snape.
If this allready have been discussed to death then I am sorry.
bye,
Nathalie
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281765 ] |
So, 11 Juni 2006 10:38 |
|
Cerridwen wrote:
> In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
> But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
And he just let Harry go because...?
Catherine Johnson.
--
fenm at cox dot net
"I'm the impish officer of death."
-Mike Nelson, _Mystery Science Theater 3000_.
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281769 ] |
So, 11 Juni 2006 11:35 |
|
"Fish Eye no Miko" <fisheye [at] deadmoon.circus> schreef in bericht
news:rEQig.8543$_c1.6579 [at] fed1read05...
> Cerridwen wrote:
>
>> In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
>> But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
>
> And he just let Harry go because...?
>
> Catherine Johnson.
> --
> fenm at cox dot net
> "I'm the impish officer of death."
> -Mike Nelson, _Mystery Science Theater 3000_.
>
Shoot!
I thought I cancelled this message :-(
I was ready with typing before my brain told me that this idea was
ridiculous.
Then again, maybe he let Harry go because of more dramatich plans he has in
store for him.
Nevermind
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281774 ] |
So, 11 Juni 2006 13:34 |
|
Fish Eye no Miko wrote:
> Cerridwen wrote:
>
> > In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
> > But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
>
> And he just let Harry go because...?
...he recently realised that harry is a horcrux of his? :D <takes tongue
outta cheek>
---
Jane Grey
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281803 ] |
So, 11 Juni 2006 20:04 |
|
Cerridwen wrote:
> "Fish Eye no Miko" <fisheye [at] deadmoon.circus> schreef:
>> Cerridwen wrote:
>>
>>> In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's
>>> side appearently. But what if he wasn't Snape but
>>> Voldemort himself?
>>
>> And he just let Harry go because...?
>
> Shoot!
> I thought I cancelled this message :-(
Ooops... )-:
> I was ready with typing before my brain told me that this idea was
> ridiculous.
I've certainly heard more ridiculous ones. Heck, yours actually made me
stop and think instead of, say, roll my eyes and move on to the next post.
^_^
> Then again, maybe he let Harry go because of more dramatich plans
> he has in store for him.
OOoooh.. O_O
> Nevermind
Oh. Ok. ^_^
Catherine Johnson.
--
fenm at cox dot net
"Don't go to Europe to 'find yourself'. Who told you that you were over
there, anyway?"
-Stephen Colbert, _The Colbert Report_.
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281818 ] |
Mo, 12 Juni 2006 02:03 |
|
Jane,
Snape my be evil, but he is playing his own game.
And his game does NOT include LV what ever it is.
His game came closer to DD, and what ever its, If were
LV I would be very afraid of Snape.
1)Because Snape is you equal.
2)Because Snape could destroy you.
As Snape Killing DD, I am convinced that DD ask him to kill him.
Snape is like Fenamore in Dune, hidden.
I will eventually be Snape and Harry together that will destroy LV.
Chip
Jane Grey wrote:
> Fish Eye no Miko wrote:
>
>>Cerridwen wrote:
>>
>>
>>>In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
>>>But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
>>
>>And he just let Harry go because...?
>
>
> ..he recently realised that harry is a horcrux of his? :D <takes tongue
> outta cheek>
>
> ---
> Jane Grey
>
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281833 ] |
Mo, 12 Juni 2006 09:39 |
|
On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 10:01:39 +0200, "Cerridwen" <miauw751 [at] hotmail.com>
wrote:
>Hi, don't post here much but I have a question, and it hasn't been mentioned
>as far as I know.
>In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
>But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
>We've seen Polly Juice potion a couple of times now.
Voldemort would never make an Unbreakable Vow where he's the one who
could die. He wanted Draco to fail so he could kill off the Malfoy
Clan.
>Makes more scense that Wormtail was staying with him plus the title half
>blood prince makes more sence to me.
as who? Not Voldemort? He's not the HBP.
>Not to mention the look of hatred on Snape's face when he killed DD and the
Being forced to kill your only supporter does that to you.
>alledged fault Dumbledore made when trusting Snape.
But he didn't, because he could. Trus him to kill him, even.
>If this allready have been discussed to death then I am sorry.
The only thing dead is Dumbledore. And Sirius. The Potters. Etc.
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281834 ] |
Mo, 12 Juni 2006 09:44 |
|
On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 01:38:48 -0700, "Fish Eye no Miko"
<fisheye [at] deadmoon.circus> wrote:
>Cerridwen wrote:
>
>> In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
>> But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
>
>And he just let Harry go because...?
>
>Catherine Johnson.
Dr. Who Marathon was starting. And for some reason The Doctor bears a
striking resemblance to Barty Crouch Jr.
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281835 ] |
Mo, 12 Juni 2006 09:45 |
|
On 11 Jun 2006 04:34:32 -0700, "Jane Grey" <jane.grey [at] hotmail.co.uk>
wrote:
>Fish Eye no Miko wrote:
>> Cerridwen wrote:
>>
>> > In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
>> > But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
>>
>> And he just let Harry go because...?
>
>..he recently realised that harry is a horcrux of his? :D <takes tongue
>outta cheek>
>
>---
>Jane Grey
Yup. Always a possibility. : P
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281836 ] |
Mo, 12 Juni 2006 09:46 |
|
On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 20:03:53 -0400, R Black
<racblack [at] NOSPAMinmtrex..XXXnet> wrote:
>1)Because Snape is you equal.
Only Harry is.
>2)Because Snape could destroy you.
Only Harry can
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281847 ] |
Mo, 12 Juni 2006 16:30 |
|
"Toon" <toon [at] toon.com> schreef in bericht
news:dd6q82hhj9mmp9b5c1a7rjnlam1flv4lts [at] 4ax.com...
> On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 10:01:39 +0200, "Cerridwen" <miauw751 [at] hotmail.com>
> wrote:
>
>>Hi, don't post here much but I have a question, and it hasn't been
>>mentioned
>>as far as I know.
>>In HBP we see that Snape has turned to Voldemort's side appearently.
>>But what if he wasn't Snape but Voldemort himself?
>>We've seen Polly Juice potion a couple of times now.
>
> Voldemort would never make an Unbreakable Vow where he's the one who
> could die. He wanted Draco to fail so he could kill off the Malfoy
> Clan.
>
>>Makes more scense that Wormtail was staying with him plus the title half
>>blood prince makes more sence to me.
>
> as who? Not Voldemort? He's not the HBP.
>
>>Not to mention the look of hatred on Snape's face when he killed DD and
>>the
>
> Being forced to kill your only supporter does that to you.
>
>>alledged fault Dumbledore made when trusting Snape.
>
> But he didn't, because he could. Trus him to kill him, even.
>
>>If this allready have been discussed to death then I am sorry.
>
> The only thing dead is Dumbledore. And Sirius. The Potters. Etc.
>
Hi Toon,
You are right this theory is wobbly at best.
But as for the unbreakable vow.. why not, you don't know what will happen to
the person when he has horcruxes at hand. And besides that, we know he is a
megalomaniac. What if he was sure he could protect Draco PLUS having the
benefits later to kill off his family because of treason? Then he had no
problem at all to explain their deaths to other death eaters. (as if he
would be bothered to explain himself)
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281849 ] |
Mo, 12 Juni 2006 19:55 |
|
Toon wrote:
> >If this allready have been discussed to death then I am sorry.
>
> The only thing dead is Dumbledore. And Sirius. The Potters. Etc.
The Harry Horcrux Theory?
=)
-Aaron
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281892 ] |
Di, 13 Juni 2006 07:01 |
|
On Mon, 12 Jun 2006 16:30:14 +0200, "Cerridwen" <miauw751 [at] hotmail.com>
wrote:
>
>You are right this theory is wobbly at best.
>But as for the unbreakable vow.. why not, you don't know what will happen to
>the person when he has horcruxes at hand. And besides that, we know he is a
>megalomaniac. What if he was sure he could protect Draco PLUS having the
>benefits later to kill off his family because of treason? Then he had no
>problem at all to explain their deaths to other death eaters. (as if he
>would be bothered to explain himself)
>
He already lived through Horcrux survival once. He lost his troops,
his reputation, his life (as he knew it) for 13 years. He's not going
to risk it all again unless necessary. And he fears death so much,
he'd never do anything that results in death unless absolutely
necessary.
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #281894 ] |
Di, 13 Juni 2006 07:47 |
|
> He already lived through Horcrux survival once. He lost his troops,
> his reputation, his life (as he knew it) for 13 years. He's not going
> to risk it all again unless necessary. And he fears death so much,
> he'd never do anything that results in death unless absolutely
> necessary.
Yep you're right.
This theory is dead.
*Off to ponder other possibilities*
bye now,
Nathalie
|
|
|
| Re: A crazy idea [message #282134 ] |
Sa, 17 Juni 2006 15:32 |
|
Toon wrote:
> On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 20:03:53 -0400, R Black
> <racblack [at] NOSPAMinmtrex..XXXnet> wrote:
>
> >1)Because Snape is you equal.
>
> Only Harry is.
>
> >2)Because Snape could destroy you.
>
> Only Harry can
and Snape is too scared to even say Voldemort:
'How come I saw through the snakes eyes if it's Voldemort's thoughts
I'm sharing?'
'Do not say the Dark Lord's name!' spat Snape.
There was a nasty silence. They glared at each other across the
Pensieve.
'Professor Dumbledore says his name,' said Harry quietly.
'Dumbledore is an extremely powerful wizard,' Snape muttered. 'While he
may feel secure enough to use the name... the rest of us...' He rubbed
his left forearm, apparently unconsciously, on the spot where Harry
knew the Dark Mark was burned into his skin.
rac, there is nothing that special about Snape, he just seems to be a
bitter man who was once a DE and has since turned sides.
--
Jane Grey
|
|
|
