Sprinkler Systems Uhaul move Lawn care Roses and trees Ford Parts Chrysler Parts Lake Powell New IPod Touch Apps New IPhone Apps IPhone Apps IPad Information IPad Apps Android APPS Android Games APPS Android Systems Android Tablets APPS and Beyond Smartphone Apps Smartphone Games Apps Repair and Tools Tablet PC Car Sharing Car Leasing Tabler Pc Fly Fishing Toyota Cars Vacation Rentals Stock market NYSE SSE Stock Freight & Shipping News Gluten Lactose Gout My Coupon Life Campgrounds Check Outdoor Kitchen Design and Redoo Bath Remodeling Palm Springs Las Vegas Vacation Tipps Lake Powell Boating Homes for lease Electric and green Car Blog Pearls and diamonds Whatsapp and forget SMS Blog, What is Whatsapp App Solar Panel Solar Energie Sun Power Blog
Reader


[Suche]  [Administrator]  [Hinweise zum Reader]  [Startseite]
Fantasy » alt.fan.harry-potter » Another GOF Movie Clue
Another GOF Movie Clue [message #239867] Di, 28 März 2006 15:22
Toon  
When Cedric's hit with AK, he goes flying backwards a bit. Now, what
if he was on a tower at the time?

The real question this invokes is, would JK allow a different effect
to occur then she wrote? If AK can not possibly send one flying,
wouldn't she have objected to that scene? Easily fixed to have Cedric
collapse to the ground. It's as if the force of the blast sends one
flying backwards. And I don't think we've seen someone's full AK
death. Just Moddy's spider, which seemed to be squashed, possibly
from the angle of aiming down on it.

Could the level of hatred behind the desire to kill make one go
flying?

And would JK make sure that the full effect of a spell is portrayed if
it seems contrary to what has been written, because nobody's death has
been detailed like in a movie script. IE, AK and died, not AK, fell
backwards, crashed into the ground, breaking table along the way.
Re: Another GOF Movie Clue [message #239880 ] Di, 28 März 2006 17:26
tbarry22  
Toon wrote:
> When Cedric's hit with AK, he goes flying backwards a bit. Now, what
> if he was on a tower at the time?
>
> The real question this invokes is, would JK allow a different effect
> to occur then she wrote? If AK can not possibly send one flying,
> wouldn't she have objected to that scene? Easily fixed to have Cedric
> collapse to the ground. It's as if the force of the blast sends one
> flying backwards. And I don't think we've seen someone's full AK
> death. Just Moddy's spider, which seemed to be squashed, possibly
> from the angle of aiming down on it.
>
> Could the level of hatred behind the desire to kill make one go
> flying?
>
> And would JK make sure that the full effect of a spell is portrayed if
> it seems contrary to what has been written, because nobody's death has
> been detailed like in a movie script. IE, AK and died, not AK, fell
> backwards, crashed into the ground, breaking table along the way.

Well, the books and the movies aren't the same. The movie is called an
adaptation, not a literal translation. Therefore they have a degree of
artistic license.
Re: Another GOF Movie Clue [message #239900 ] Di, 28 März 2006 19:48
pooter  
Toon [toon [at] toon.com] said
> When Cedric's hit with AK, he goes flying backwards a bit. Now, what
> if he was on a tower at the time?
>
> The real question this invokes is, would JK allow a different effect
> to occur then she wrote? If AK can not possibly send one flying,
> wouldn't she have objected to that scene? Easily fixed to have Cedric
> collapse to the ground. It's as if the force of the blast sends one
> flying backwards. And I don't think we've seen someone's full AK
> death. Just Moddy's spider, which seemed to be squashed, possibly
> from the angle of aiming down on it.
>
> Could the level of hatred behind the desire to kill make one go
> flying?
>
> And would JK make sure that the full effect of a spell is portrayed if
> it seems contrary to what has been written, because nobody's death has
> been detailed like in a movie script. IE, AK and died, not AK, fell
> backwards, crashed into the ground, breaking table along the way.
>

The films are for effect and JKR didn't write them.
Re: Another GOF Movie Clue [message #239915 ] Di, 28 März 2006 23:06
Fish Eye no Miko  
Toon wrote:

> When Cedric's hit with AK, he goes flying backwards a bit. Now,
> what if he was on a tower at the time?
> The real question this invokes is, would JK allow a different effect
> to occur then she wrote?

I've said it before, and I'll say it again: When Harry opens his eyes,
Cedric is spread-eagle on the ground,. That does NOT happen if one just
collapses where they stand. I think he DID go flying a bit, and Harry just
didn't have his eyes open to see it happen.

Catherine Johnson.
--
fenm at cox dot net
Right now you are reading my .sig quote.
Re: Another GOF Movie Clue [message #239925 ] Mi, 29 März 2006 02:34
wadkin2000  
pooter wrote:
> Toon [toon [at] toon.com] said
> > When Cedric's hit with AK, he goes flying backwards a bit. Now, what
> > if he was on a tower at the time?
> >
> > The real question this invokes is, would JK allow a different effect
> > to occur then she wrote? If AK can not possibly send one flying,
> > wouldn't she have objected to that scene? Easily fixed to have Cedric
> > collapse to the ground. It's as if the force of the blast sends one
> > flying backwards. And I don't think we've seen someone's full AK
> > death. Just Moddy's spider, which seemed to be squashed, possibly
> > from the angle of aiming down on it.
> >
> > Could the level of hatred behind the desire to kill make one go
> > flying?
> >
> > And would JK make sure that the full effect of a spell is portrayed if
> > it seems contrary to what has been written, because nobody's death has
> > been detailed like in a movie script. IE, AK and died, not AK, fell
> > backwards, crashed into the ground, breaking table along the way.
> >
>
> The films are for effect and JKR didn't write them.


What I find strange is that in the GOF book and movie, there was a
very, very small number of Death Eaters (in the movie it looked as if
there were around ten). There were how many thousands and thousands of
wizards at the Cup? I know that the Death Eaters were dreadfully
feared, but even if 1/2% of the wizards at the Cup stunned or cursed
them immediately, all of them would have been in Azkaban at once.
(Obviously, there wouldn't have been much more of a plot, but you get
my drift)
Re: Another GOF Movie Clue [message #239932 ] Mi, 29 März 2006 03:35
Magic_mom  
wadkin2000 [at] yahoo.com wrote:


> What I find strange is that in the GOF book and movie, there was a
> very, very small number of Death Eaters (in the movie it looked as if
> there were around ten). There were how many thousands and thousands of
> wizards at the Cup? I know that the Death Eaters were dreadfully
> feared, but even if 1/2% of the wizards at the Cup stunned or cursed
> them immediately, all of them would have been in Azkaban at once.
> (Obviously, there wouldn't have been much more of a plot, but you get
> my drift)

Yep.. Just a hundred wizards and "STUPEFY" would have done the trick.

M_m
Vorheriges Thema:Cedric and V's Wand?
Nächstes Thema:Harry Potter Chess in Germany
Gehe zu:
  


aktuelle Zeit: Fr Mai 25 20:44:28 CEST 2012

Insgesamt benötigte Zeit, um die Seite zu erzeugen: 0,02498 Sekunden
.:: Startseite - Hinweise - Impressum ::.

Powered