| DD speculates Nagini is the missing Horcrux [message #239174] |
Mi, 22 März 2006 05:28 |
|
If V created his last Horcrux after murdering Frank Brice then
Wormtail would certainly know about it as he was there and V was
quite helpless (couldnt feed himself) without his assistance. Would
the very secretive V allow Wormtail to know one of his most guarded
secrets?
|
|
|
| Re: DD speculates Nagini is the missing Horcrux [message #239190 ] |
Mi, 22 März 2006 09:43 |
|
On Tue, 21 Mar 2006 20:28:24 -0800, "Steve Szostek" <nospam [at] here.com>
wrote:
>If V created his last Horcrux after murdering Frank Brice then
>Wormtail would certainly know about it as he was there and V was
>quite helpless (couldnt feed himself) without his assistance. Would
>the very secretive V allow Wormtail to know one of his most guarded
>secrets?
>
>
Do you really think Nagini can't take Wormtail?
|
|
|
| Re: DD speculates Nagini is the missing Horcrux [message #239232 ] |
Mi, 22 März 2006 15:06 |
|
In article <Lm4Uf.27$kT4.2 [at] fed1read02>, "Steve Szostek" <nospam [at] here.com> wrote:
>If V created his last Horcrux after murdering Frank Brice then
>Wormtail would certainly know about it as he was there and V was
>quite helpless (couldnt feed himself) without his assistance. Would
>the very secretive V allow Wormtail to know one of his most guarded
>secrets?
I think it depends on how *fresh* the soul fragment needs to be. Frank
Bryce was murdered at the beginning of GoF. LV could have made Nagini a
Horcrux anytime after being resurrected in the graveyard without Wormtail
knowing about it.
Read exactly what DD says in HBP, Ch. 23:
"After an interval of some years, however, he used Nagini to kill an old
Muggle man, and it might then have occurred to him to turn her into his
last Horcrux."
He says LV got the idea after killing the old Muggle. He doesn't say that
LV actually used that murder to create a Nagini Horcrux. There were also a
few murders in OotP and HBP.
--
Chris
|
|
|
| Re: DD speculates Nagini is the missing Horcrux [message #244038 ] |
Mo, 03 April 2006 05:27 |
|
The Three remaing Horecrux are,
1) harrys Scare,
2) Huffenpuffs cup.
3) Gryfindors Sword.
Chip
Green-Eyed Chris wrote:
> In article <Lm4Uf.27$kT4.2 [at] fed1read02>, "Steve Szostek" <nospam [at] here.com> wrote:
>
>
>>If V created his last Horcrux after murdering Frank Brice then
>>Wormtail would certainly know about it as he was there and V was
>>quite helpless (couldnt feed himself) without his assistance. Would
>>the very secretive V allow Wormtail to know one of his most guarded
>>secrets?
>
>
> I think it depends on how *fresh* the soul fragment needs to be. Frank
> Bryce was murdered at the beginning of GoF. LV could have made Nagini a
> Horcrux anytime after being resurrected in the graveyard without Wormtail
> knowing about it.
>
> Read exactly what DD says in HBP, Ch. 23:
>
> "After an interval of some years, however, he used Nagini to kill an old
> Muggle man, and it might then have occurred to him to turn her into his
> last Horcrux."
>
> He says LV got the idea after killing the old Muggle. He doesn't say that
> LV actually used that murder to create a Nagini Horcrux. There were also a
> few murders in OotP and HBP.
> --
> Chris
|
|
|
| Re: DD speculates Nagini is the missing Horcrux [message #245580 ] |
Do, 06 April 2006 10:42 |
|
On 2006-04-02 23:27:39 -0400, R Black <racblack [at] NOSPAMinmtrex..XXXnet> said:
> The Three remaing Horecrux are,
> 1) harrys Scare,
> 2) Huffenpuffs cup.
> 3) Gryfindors Sword.
>
> Chip
So sure of that, are you?
--
Enjoy,
Zolak of Twylo
|
|
|
| Re: DD speculates Nagini is the missing Horcrux [message #245911 ] |
So, 09 April 2006 19:50 |
|
Steve Szostek <nospam [at] here.com> wrote:
> If V created his last Horcrux after murdering Frank Brice then
> Wormtail would certainly know about it as he was there and V was
> quite helpless (couldnt feed himself) without his assistance. Would
> the very secretive V allow Wormtail to know one of his most guarded
> secrets?
Why would Wormtail even what a Horcrux is? Voldemort could have
cast the spell right in front of him without him even realising,
especially if it was done non-verbally.
|
|
|
