| school song [message #238284] |
Mi, 15 März 2006 14:13 |
|
JKR say that the school song is heard when DD is in a good mood. Now he is
dead(?) does that mean we will not hear the school song again, or will the
new head have it sung?
|
|
|
| Re: school song [message #238315 ] |
Mi, 15 März 2006 22:24 |
|
mewthree [paul [at] mewthree.plus.com] said
> JKR say that the school song is heard when DD is in a good mood. Now he is
> dead(?) does that mean we will not hear the school song again, or will the
> new head have it sung?
>
>
>
Dunno. Do you know?
|
|
|
| Re: school song [message #238319 ] |
Do, 16 März 2006 01:22 |
|
"mewthree" <paul [at] mewthree.plus.com> wrote in message
news:jqURf.185686$YJ4.142287 [at] fe2.news.blueyonder.co.uk...
> JKR say that the school song is heard when DD is in a good mood. Now he is
> dead(?) does that mean we will not hear the school song again, or will the
> new head have it sung?
Maybe the "new head" will consult Dumbledore's painting in the office and
act on his advice? That is assuming that he is actually dead - there are
many conflicting theories on this. Personally I would wait until JKR writes
the seventh book - read it and find out - but that is a pretty "boring" way
with no cause for speculation which for some people is half the fun...
--
-=# Amos E Wolfe #=-
AIM: Traindriver9334
Save Gales Brewery - http://www.savegales.org.uk/
|
|
|
| Re: school song [message #238320 ] |
Do, 16 März 2006 02:01 |
|
Amos E Wolfe escribió:
> "mewthree" <paul [at] mewthree.plus.com> wrote in message
> news:jqURf.185686$YJ4.142287 [at] fe2.news.blueyonder.co.uk...
>> JKR say that the school song is heard when DD is in a good mood. Now he is
>> dead(?) does that mean we will not hear the school song again, or will the
>> new head have it sung?
>
> Maybe the "new head" will consult Dumbledore's painting in the office and
> act on his advice? That is assuming that he is actually dead - there are
> many conflicting theories on this. Personally I would wait until JKR writes
> the seventh book - read it and find out - but that is a pretty "boring" way
> with no cause for speculation which for some people is half the fun...
>
First, deal with it: is dead.
Two, Why would the new HM have to consult with him or any portrait? Did
DD was the first Head to sing the song? Doubt it. Surely that's a
tradition since the first days of Hogwarts and simply DD didn't felt
like singing it every year because he's a rebel ;), so, it depends on
the Headmaster.
So, if Umbridge where Headmistress again, they would sing it every day
:S (I remember we used to sing the national anthem and the School song
every Monday...)
|
|
|
| Re: school song [message #238343 ] |
Do, 16 März 2006 07:02 |
|
On Thu, 16 Mar 2006 00:22:56 GMT, "Amos E Wolfe"
<amos.wolfe [at] ntlworld.com> wrote:
>"mewthree" <paul [at] mewthree.plus.com> wrote in message
>news:jqURf.185686$YJ4.142287 [at] fe2.news.blueyonder.co.uk...
>> JKR say that the school song is heard when DD is in a good mood. Now he is
>> dead(?) does that mean we will not hear the school song again, or will the
>> new head have it sung?
>
>Maybe the "new head" will consult Dumbledore's painting in the office and
>act on his advice? That is assuming that he is actually dead - there are
>many conflicting theories on this. Personally I would wait until JKR writes
>the seventh book - read it and find out - but that is a pretty "boring" way
>with no cause for speculation which for some people is half the fun...
and some people still won't accept the book answer, finding some
alleged loophole to prove their point.
|
|
|
| Re: school song [message #238344 ] |
Do, 16 März 2006 07:01 |
|
On Wed, 15 Mar 2006 13:13:51 GMT, "mewthree" <paul [at] mewthree.plus.com>
wrote:
>JKR say that the school song is heard when DD is in a good mood. Now he is
>dead(?) does that mean we will not hear the school song again, or will the
>new head have it sung?
>
Depdns on if McG's in a good mood.
|
|
|
| Re: school song [message #238449 ] |
Fr, 17 März 2006 09:47 |
|
In article <jqURf.185686$YJ4.142287 [at] fe2.news.blueyonder.co.uk>,
mewthree <paul [at] mewthree.plus.com> wrote:
>JKR say that the school song is heard when DD is in a good mood. Now he is
>dead(?) does that mean we will not hear the school song again, or will the
>new head have it sung?
Within the book, the question doesn't arise, since that came from an interview.
However, since JKR did say that, perhaps his painting will be heard singing at
some point in the story.
=Tamar
|
|
|
