| GOF Movie and Snape is Evil Theory # 10000 [message #231678] |
So, 12 März 2006 04:08 |
|
Ok, I finally finished GOF again, and this time, there are 2 hints that
Snape is Evil, one is during the trial when Igor says that "It's a lie,
Snape is still loyal to Voldemort." Now that we know what happens with book
6, this statement has more meaning.
The 2nd is when Snape convinces dumbledore to let everything play out and
use Potter as bait. Now at first blush, you can say it's typical Snape and
his hatred of Harry. But what if he suspected something, and instead of
stopping V like he did in the first time out.
|
|
|
| Re: GOF Movie and Snape is Evil Theory # 10000 [message #231682 ] |
So, 12 März 2006 05:23 |
|
ergrtgth wrote:
> Ok, I finally finished GOF again, and this time, there are 2 hints
> that Snape is Evil, one is during the trial when Igor says that
> "It's a lie, Snape is still loyal to Voldemort." Now that we know
> what happens with book 6, this statement has more meaning.
Well, no, cuz 1) movie are not written by Jo and are not canon, and 2) You
think Snape would have told Karkakoff that he was a spy?
> The 2nd is when Snape convinces dumbledore to let everything
> play out and use Potter as bait. Now at first blush, you can say
> it's typical Snape and his hatred of Harry. But what if he
> suspected something, and instead of stopping V like he did in
> the first time out.
Is this last sentence complete? "Instead of stopping V like he did..." he
what?
Catherine Johnson.
--
fenm at cox dot net
"I believe that if anything is worth doing, it would have been done
already."
|
|
|
| Re: GOF Movie and Snape is Evil Theory # 10000 [message #231744 ] |
So, 12 März 2006 19:37 |
|
ergrtgth wrote:
> Ok, I finally finished GOF again, and this time, there are 2 hints that
> Snape is Evil, one is during the trial when Igor says that "It's a lie,
> Snape is still loyal to Voldemort." Now that we know what happens with book
> 6, this statement has more meaning.
>
>
> The 2nd is when Snape convinces dumbledore to let everything play out and
> use Potter as bait. Now at first blush, you can say it's typical Snape and
> his hatred of Harry. But what if he suspected something, and instead of
> stopping V like he did in the first time out.
>
>
And while I agree - there is one BIG hint that Snape is trusted and
trustworthy. In the scene in Moody's office where Barty Crouch JR is
finally "unmasked" - everyone leaves except Snape - who is left with JR.
Presumably - JR - would know that Snape was a DE and would also know if
Snape was loyal to Riddle. Since they all escaped Azkaban when the
Dementors went with Riddle - that would have been brought back to Riddle.
|
|
|
