| Snape Theory [message #144321] |
Do, 06 Oktober 2005 09:59 |
|
What I think is that Snape is up to something much bigger than just being a
Death Eater. He is not really a Voldemort's man in his mind. He is posing
as one and Voldermort considers him an important servant, but from his
history and character it looks like he has his own secret agenda. He might
be even preparing his own plans to lead the dark world. To take over the
Dark Side he may be even planning to kill Voldermort.
He is very patient, strong and smart. With his infinite patience and
loyalty he wins his masters' unlimited trust, only to strike when his time
comes. He fooled such a wise and powerful wizard as Dumbledore for so long,
he might be fooling Voldermort right now.
My theory about the book 7 is this: first Snape kills Voldermort and takes
over, then in the main showdown of all the series Harry finishes Snape with
the help of Ginny and others.
|
|
|
| Re: Snape Theory [message #144365 ] |
Do, 06 Oktober 2005 16:08 |
|
Morlock wrote:
> What I think is that Snape is up to something much bigger than just being a
> Death Eater. He is not really a Voldemort's man in his mind. He is posing
> as one and Voldermort considers him an important servant, but from his
> history and character it looks like he has his own secret agenda. He might
> be even preparing his own plans to lead the dark world. To take over the
> Dark Side he may be even planning to kill Voldermort.
> He is very patient, strong and smart. With his infinite patience and
> loyalty he wins his masters' unlimited trust, only to strike when his time
> comes. He fooled such a wise and powerful wizard as Dumbledore for so long,
> he might be fooling Voldermort right now.
> My theory about the book 7 is this: first Snape kills Voldermort and takes
> over, then in the main showdown of all the series Harry finishes Snape with
> the help of Ginny and others.
I don't find this particulary likely. Snape seems to me to have the
brains and abilities to maybe try to pull this off, but does not seem
to be a person who would want this. (If he thinks Hogwarts Potions
students are dunderheads, wait until he's giving orders to Death
Eaters!)
But the biggest objection I would make is the Prophecy...
|
|
|
| Re: Snape Theory [message #144475 ] |
Fr, 07 Oktober 2005 03:07 |
|
|
Post removed (X-No-Archive: yes)
|
|
|
| Re: Snape Theory [message #144491 ] |
Fr, 07 Oktober 2005 06:44 |
|
Don Reeves <don [at] donreeves.com> wrote in
news:l8ibk1d4u6g7sqdejl7s89ca14e0tk62us [at] 4ax.com:
> On Thu, 06 Oct 2005 02:59:57 -0500, Morlock <morlock [at] gazeta.pl> wrote:
>
>>What I think is that Snape is up to something much bigger than just
>>being a Death Eater. He is not really a Voldemort's man in his mind.
>>He is posing as one and Voldermort considers him an important servant,
>>but from his history and character it looks like he has his own secret
>>agenda. He might be even preparing his own plans to lead the dark
>>world. To take over the Dark Side he may be even planning to kill
>>Voldermort. He is very patient, strong and smart. With his infinite
>>patience and loyalty he wins his masters' unlimited trust, only to
>>strike when his time comes. He fooled such a wise and powerful wizard
>>as Dumbledore for so long, he might be fooling Voldermort right now.
>>My theory about the book 7 is this: first Snape kills Voldermort and
>>takes over, then in the main showdown of all the series Harry finishes
>>Snape with the help of Ginny and others.
>
> The general theory that Snape is acting as his own man has been
> discussed before. I believe that this is highly likely except that
> Snape will not be the one to kill Voldemort. He knows that the
> prophecy predicts that Harry will do that. The reason (in this theory)
> that Snape didn't harm Harry at the end of HBP is that his plan is to
> wait for Harry to dispose of Voldy. He can then kill Harry himself.
> Don Reeves
Yes, this makes a perfect sense and is actually very likely to happen.It
puts all the pieces together. Thanks for this splendid idea.
Snape weakness is, what he said himself in his conversation with
Narcissa: he underestimates Harry.
|
|
|
| Re: Snape Theory [message #146612 ] |
Sa, 08 Oktober 2005 05:21 |
|
Morlock wrote:
> What I think is that Snape is up to something much bigger than just being a
> Death Eater. He is not really a Voldemort's man in his mind. He is posing
> as one and Voldermort considers him an important servant, but from his
> history and character it looks like he has his own secret agenda. He might
> be even preparing his own plans to lead the dark world. To take over the
> Dark Side he may be even planning to kill Voldermort.
"Join me, Harry, and together we will rule the Galaxy!"
Oops, wrong mythos.
|
|
|
| Re: Snape Theory [message #224096 ] |
Mo, 27 Februar 2006 20:05 |
|
I am your father . . .
uh wait, wrong group . . .ha!
|
|
|
